Jump to content

User talk:ToBeFree

Page contents not supported in other languages.
Add topic
From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia
Latest comment: 23 minutes ago by MediaWiki message delivery in topic Administrators' newsletter – November 2026
To add this button to your own talk page, you can use {{User new message large}}. It can easily be modified: Colorful examples are provided on the "Template:User new message large" page.

WikiProject or others adding article requirements more stringent than WP policies

[edit]

I believe you mentioned before about WikiProjects or others adding article requirements that were more stringent than Wikipedia policies. I believe you were skeptical about the propriety of this.

Can you think of some examples? I seek to study this issue first because it may or may not be relevant in a current ArbCom case. Thank you. Vanguard10 (talk) 23:37, 31 October 2026 (UTC)Reply

Hello Vanguard10, this is now at ArbCom? Okay ...
I couldn't find it anymore but I knew I had encountered this years ago, so I have now built a local database of all my contributions ever and searched through that. 😅
  • ("WikiProject overturning RSN result")
  • , (I objected to "Any result that is not referenced or that is not the same as in Sherdog, must be returned to how it is described in Sherdog" being treated by WP:MMA as if it was a holy super-policy overriding others).
Courtesy ping: Cassiopeia.
Best regards,
~ ToBeFree (talk) 04:23, 1 November 2026 (UTC)Reply
Thank you.
I am very surprised, but Danners430 and his issues took me to ArbCom. I do not want to fight. I have even retired from Wikipedia at least for 2026 and likely 2027. But I must respond but I will do so graciously.
Vanguard10 (talk) 04:29, 1 November 2026 (UTC)Reply

The Signpost: 1 November 2026

[edit]
  • By the numbers: Wikipedian Nobel Prize 2026
    Which language versions of Wikipedia had biographies of laureates before Nobel announcements?
  • On the bright side: Gone fishing
    Touring Thailand, exploring iridescence, and translating prairie dog.

Administrators' newsletter – November 2026

[edit]

News and updates for administrators from the past month (October 2026).

Administrator changes

added
readded
removed

Guideline and policy news

  • Following an RfC, election to ArbCom now requires at least 60% support. Successful candidates normally serve two-year terms, with one-year terms retained for filling vacancies. Proposals to change the election rules may now be added throughout the year and discussed on the talk page; formal discussion remains in September.
  • Following an RfC, first-time reviewers’ reviews require an experienced reviewer’s check, and GA requirements now include alt text and accessible tables. Featured articles may receive GA status during removal discussions if they meet GA criteria. Backlog drives will run every five months, with a points leaderboard and awards for the top five participants.

Miscellaneous